Loft, extension or garage , which buys a square metre cheapest?
Compares only the options you actually have. Set anything you cannot do to “not possible”.
A typical UK three-bed semi is about 90 to 100m². Habitable space only, not the garage
| Option | Space | Total cost | Per m² | Value added | Net |
|---|
Set at least one option to something other than “not possible”.
How this is calculated, and which numbers to trust
The cost figures are the solid part. Garage rates are £450-£750 per m² integral, £805-£1,100 attached and £1,100-£1,700 detached (MyJobQuote, 5 Nov 2026 , the detached band also covers high-specification work). Loft rates are total-project figures of £1,200-£1,800 for a rooflight conversion up to £1,900-£2,900 for a mansard (Best Builders, Aug 2026). Extension rates are £950-£2,200 per m² depending on storeys and finish, including professional fees and contingency (MyJobQuote, Oct 2026). Regional multipliers are the same ones used across this site, London at +30%.
The value column is modelled, not guessed. Most sites quote uplift percentages lifted from builders and trade directories, which is marketing material rather than valuation research. We use a published rule instead: “A 10% increase in floor space adds around 5% to the value of a typical house”, from Andrew Harvey, senior economist at Nationwide, based on analysis of their House Price Index (reported October 2025). So the value shown is half the proportional increase in your floor area, applied to the value you entered. That is why we ask how big your home is now: the same 30m² loft is worth far more on a small house than on a large one.
Bedrooms beat floor area, and this model cannot see them. Nationwide’s own point is that extra bedrooms are what really move a price. A double bedroom plus a bathroom added to a three-bed, one-bath house can lift it by as much as 24%, and a detached house going from two bedrooms to three by up to 17%. Where your project creates a proper bedroom, read the value column as a floor, not a ceiling.
What the model deliberately ignores. Your local ceiling price, which overrides everything: in a street where houses stop at a certain figure, no amount of floor area pushes past it. Quality of finish. Whether losing the garage costs you parking. And the fact that a 10% floor-space increase on a flat is not the same thing as on a detached house.
The real limit is your local ceiling price. In a street where houses cap out at a certain figure, no amount of extra floor area pushes past it. A local estate agent will tell you that number in one phone call, and it overrides everything on this page.
Figures are reviewed each April, when building costs are typically repriced. These are published guide prices, not quotes.